New York Times, Feb 9, 2011
Representatives Jerrold Nadler, left, and Milke Quigley, both Democrats, on Tuesday with the president of Naral, Nancy Keenan.
Invoking the mantra of fiscal restraint that has dominated House action since lawmakers reconvened last month, Republicans began committee work this week on two bills that would greatly expand restrictions on financing for and access to abortions. Another bill, one that would cut off federal dollars to women’s health care clinics that offer abortions, is expected to surface later this year.
“This House is more pro-life than it’s ever been,” said Representative Joe Pitts, Republican of Pennsylvania and the author of one of the bills to limit money for abortions.
Democrats in both the House and Senate immediately fought back Tuesday, working closely with reproductive rights advocates. They have appropriated the Republican charge from last year that Democrats were working on a liberal policy agenda instead of on job creation and the economy, and turned it on its head.
“This election was about the economy,” said Senator Kirsten Gillibrand of New York, who joined with other Democratic senators Tuesday to decry the House bills Tuesday as needless and intrusive.
Over and over, Democrats said that by bringing up the abortion issue now, Republicans were going back on their word to focus on the budget.
Yet the bills that have surfaced on the House floor this year have been fiscal in nature, including the repeal of the health care law, which was later rejected by the Senate, and some measures designed to cut spending.
“Republicans are focused on creating a better environment for economic growth and job creation,” said Kevin Smith, a spokesman for Speaker John A. Boehner, “and that is reflected in the legislation the House is passing,”
Still, Republicans in the House are clearly energized about using their new majority to reopen debate on an important issue for conservatives, especially in the context of the health care overhaul.
On Tuesday, Representative Eric Cantor, the Republican majority leader, described the new measures as “obviously very important in terms of the priorities we set out initially in our pledge to America.”
He indicated that he expected the first version of a House bill to finance the government through the rest of the year to bar spending to carry out the health care law. That provision is likely to also be attacked by the Senate and the Obama administration.
One bill, the “No Taxpayer Funding for Abortion Act,” would eliminate tax breaks for private employers who provide health coverage if their plans offer abortion services, and would forbid women who use a flexible spending plan to use pre-tax dollars for abortions. Those restrictions would go well beyond current law prohibiting the use of federal money for abortion services.
The bill, sponsored by Representative Christopher H. Smith, Republican of New Jersey, has drawn fire over language that undercuts a longstanding exemption on the ban on using federal money for abortions in the case of rape or incest; the measure narrows the definition of rape to “forcible rape,” a term that his office has never defined. Democratic lawmakers and others repeatedly hammered on the term, saying it suggested that victims of statutory rape and other crimes could not get abortions paid for with federal money.
While Mr. Smith’s staff said last week that the term "forcible rape" would be removed from the bill, the staff of RepresentativeJerrold Nadler of New York, the top Democrat on the Judiciary Subcommittee on the Constitution, said that language remained intact as of Tuesday.
Another bill, sponsored by Mr. Pitts, addresses the health care overhaul head-on by prohibiting Americans who receive insurance through state exchanges from purchasing abortion coverage, even with their own money. The bill is essentially a resurrection of a provision in the House version of the health care law but was not in the Senate version.
The bill would also permit hospitals to refuse abortions to women, even in emergency situations, if such care would offend the conscience of the health care providers.
“Both bills are designed to drive coverage for abortion out of health insurance plans, period,” said Nancy Northup, president of the Center for Reproductive Rights.
The bills drew immediate fire from House and Senate Democrats. “We are sending a clear message to House Republicans that their agenda on women’s health is extreme,” Senator Barbara Boxer of California said at a news conference. “It breaks faith with a decades-long bipartisan compromise, and it risks the health and lives of women. It also punishes women and businesses with a tax hike if they wish to keep or buy insurance that covers a full range of reproductive health care.”
Senator Frank R. Lautenberg of New Jersey, another Democrat who joined the news conference, compared the proposals to “a Third World country that’s requiring women to wear head shawls to cover their faces even if they don’t want to do it.”
As Mr. Smith’s bill provoked a spirited back and forth at a hearing of a subcommittee of the House Judiciary Committee, it also drew praise from some outside supporters.
“The federal government should not use tax dollars to support or promote elective abortion,” Richard Doerflinger, associate director of the Secretariat of Pro-Life Activities of the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops, said in a news release.
http://www.nytimes.com/2011/02/09/us/politics/09congress.html?hp
Tuesday, February 8, 2011
A Conservative Gathering Will Test G.O.P. Hopefuls
New York Times, 9 Feb, 2011
The Caucus
The latest on President Obama, the new Congress and other news from Washington and around the nation. Join the discussion.
•FiveThirtyEight: Nate Silver's Political Calculus
•More Politics News
The three-day gathering of the Conservative Political Action Committee, which begins Thursday with more than 10,000 activists expected to convene in Washington, effectively rings the opening bell for the Republican presidential nominating contest.
There is no clear consensus for who should carry the conservative mantle among nearly a dozen Republican aspirants who will be on hand to outline early themes of their candidacies. A wide-open race presents challenges and opportunities for the roster of current or former governors and members of Congress who are working to win over or, at the very least, neutralize influential conservative activists.
The event, which has been held every winter for nearly four decades, is seen as such a command performance this year that Haley Barbour, Mitch Daniels, Newt Gingrich, Tim Pawlenty, Ron Paul, Mitt Romney and John Thune are among those who accepted invitations. Sarah Palin and Mike Huckabee have both declined, citing scheduling conflicts.
In the wake of sweeping Republican victories in last year’s Congressional elections, where Tea Party supporters rewarded candidates who pledged to uphold fiscally conservative principles and punished those who failed their conservative purity tests, the early stage of the 2012 campaign is unfolding as something of a political free-for-all. The event offers a prominent platform for candidates to introduce — or reintroduce — themselves to influential conservatives.
But that does not necessarily mean that all candidates start on the same footing, conservative leaders say, or that the presidential race will reprise the volatility of the midterm elections.
“When you’re the party that’s out of power, more than usual, you are looking at someone who can win,” said Grover Norquist, president of Americans for Tax Reform, a conference sponsor. “There are a bunch of people who are hard core, but don’t pass the laugh test at a national level.”
The potential Republican rivals, at this early stage, have been focusing most of their criticism on the Obama administration and Democrats in Congress. But the conservative forum offers an opportunity for the contenders to begin distinguishing themselves from one another, particularly on areas of conservative orthodoxy.
The attendees of the Conservative Political Action Committee, which often includes a large contingent of young activists, are not a perfect representation of Republican voters in the early tier of states that open the presidential nominating season a year from now. But the audience at the Marriott Wardman Park hotel in Washington, along with those watching the speeches on C-Span, offers the highest-profile platform yet for prospective candidates to test their messages.
Nearly all of the potential Republican speakers have appeared at the conservative gathering in previous years, but with the next presidential campaign on the horizon, the meeting provides an opportunity to create a second impression or explain pieces of their biography that could be troubling for some staunch conservatives.
Mr. Romney, for example, has endured criticism over the health care law he signed as governor of Massachusetts. Mr. Gingrich has sought to explain his support for ethanol subsidies, which many fiscal conservatives are troubled by. And Mr. Thune has faced questions about his support for the bank bailout, known as the Troubled Assets Relief Program.
“It is a chance to brand yourself,” said David A. Keene, the president of the American Conservative Union, a conference sponsor. “This is a chance for you to lay out a vision for the future to people who don’t know you or may have heard only something about you. The day when we have a perfect candidate — from anyone’s standpoint — is a day we’re never going to see.”
The candidates will also be judged in a straw poll. The survey holds no official significance, but several contenders make a significant investment into trying to win the mock election, which is often filled with suspense and intrigue. (Mr. Romney won the contest in 2007, while Mr. Paul won last year. This year, Gary Johnson, a former New Mexico governor, is also on the ballot, which organizers believe could complicate efforts for Mr. Paul because they are likely to split the libertarian vote.)
The prospective presidential field will be joined by Senator Mitch McConnell of Kentucky, the Republican leader, and several newly elected Republican members of Congress who helped the party win its House majority. The appearances could highlight the fissures among Republicans — presidential hopefuls have already started distancing themselves from Congressional leaders on issues like raising the debt ceiling — that are likely to play out when the 2012 campaign intensifies.
The Conservative Political Action Conference also is opening against a backdrop of controversy over whether a gay Republican group should have been allowed to help sponsor the event. The Family Research Council and the Heritage Foundation are among the organizations boycotting the conference because GOProud, the gay group, is participating.
The disagreement highlights the tensions among various conservative factions and raises questions about the balance between the social and fiscal priorities of Republicans that has already become part of the debate in early-voting states like Iowa, where the state’s precinct caucuses are scheduled to open the nominating contest next Feb. 6.
The first in a series of candidate forums sponsored by the Family Leader, a social conservative advocacy group, started this week in Iowa. Mr. Pawlenty, the former governor of Minnesota, fielded questions about his opposition to abortion rights and same-sex marriage. Several prospective candidates have agreed in the coming months to participate in the sessions, which are sponsored by Bob Vander Plaats, a leading conservative in Iowa.
Mr. Vander Plaats said presidential contenders needed to address a spectrum of issues, including government spending and the deficit, same-sex marriage and abortion, if they hoped to find support among many conservative voters in Iowa.
“We’re looking for an authentic conservative that would be both social and fiscal,” Mr. Vander Plaats said. “It’s going to be a big part of the vetting process.”
http://www.nytimes.com/2011/02/09/us/politics/09republicans.html?_r=1&hp
The Caucus
The latest on President Obama, the new Congress and other news from Washington and around the nation. Join the discussion.
•FiveThirtyEight: Nate Silver's Political Calculus
•More Politics News
The three-day gathering of the Conservative Political Action Committee, which begins Thursday with more than 10,000 activists expected to convene in Washington, effectively rings the opening bell for the Republican presidential nominating contest.
There is no clear consensus for who should carry the conservative mantle among nearly a dozen Republican aspirants who will be on hand to outline early themes of their candidacies. A wide-open race presents challenges and opportunities for the roster of current or former governors and members of Congress who are working to win over or, at the very least, neutralize influential conservative activists.
The event, which has been held every winter for nearly four decades, is seen as such a command performance this year that Haley Barbour, Mitch Daniels, Newt Gingrich, Tim Pawlenty, Ron Paul, Mitt Romney and John Thune are among those who accepted invitations. Sarah Palin and Mike Huckabee have both declined, citing scheduling conflicts.
In the wake of sweeping Republican victories in last year’s Congressional elections, where Tea Party supporters rewarded candidates who pledged to uphold fiscally conservative principles and punished those who failed their conservative purity tests, the early stage of the 2012 campaign is unfolding as something of a political free-for-all. The event offers a prominent platform for candidates to introduce — or reintroduce — themselves to influential conservatives.
But that does not necessarily mean that all candidates start on the same footing, conservative leaders say, or that the presidential race will reprise the volatility of the midterm elections.
“When you’re the party that’s out of power, more than usual, you are looking at someone who can win,” said Grover Norquist, president of Americans for Tax Reform, a conference sponsor. “There are a bunch of people who are hard core, but don’t pass the laugh test at a national level.”
The potential Republican rivals, at this early stage, have been focusing most of their criticism on the Obama administration and Democrats in Congress. But the conservative forum offers an opportunity for the contenders to begin distinguishing themselves from one another, particularly on areas of conservative orthodoxy.
The attendees of the Conservative Political Action Committee, which often includes a large contingent of young activists, are not a perfect representation of Republican voters in the early tier of states that open the presidential nominating season a year from now. But the audience at the Marriott Wardman Park hotel in Washington, along with those watching the speeches on C-Span, offers the highest-profile platform yet for prospective candidates to test their messages.
Nearly all of the potential Republican speakers have appeared at the conservative gathering in previous years, but with the next presidential campaign on the horizon, the meeting provides an opportunity to create a second impression or explain pieces of their biography that could be troubling for some staunch conservatives.
Mr. Romney, for example, has endured criticism over the health care law he signed as governor of Massachusetts. Mr. Gingrich has sought to explain his support for ethanol subsidies, which many fiscal conservatives are troubled by. And Mr. Thune has faced questions about his support for the bank bailout, known as the Troubled Assets Relief Program.
“It is a chance to brand yourself,” said David A. Keene, the president of the American Conservative Union, a conference sponsor. “This is a chance for you to lay out a vision for the future to people who don’t know you or may have heard only something about you. The day when we have a perfect candidate — from anyone’s standpoint — is a day we’re never going to see.”
The candidates will also be judged in a straw poll. The survey holds no official significance, but several contenders make a significant investment into trying to win the mock election, which is often filled with suspense and intrigue. (Mr. Romney won the contest in 2007, while Mr. Paul won last year. This year, Gary Johnson, a former New Mexico governor, is also on the ballot, which organizers believe could complicate efforts for Mr. Paul because they are likely to split the libertarian vote.)
The prospective presidential field will be joined by Senator Mitch McConnell of Kentucky, the Republican leader, and several newly elected Republican members of Congress who helped the party win its House majority. The appearances could highlight the fissures among Republicans — presidential hopefuls have already started distancing themselves from Congressional leaders on issues like raising the debt ceiling — that are likely to play out when the 2012 campaign intensifies.
The Conservative Political Action Conference also is opening against a backdrop of controversy over whether a gay Republican group should have been allowed to help sponsor the event. The Family Research Council and the Heritage Foundation are among the organizations boycotting the conference because GOProud, the gay group, is participating.
The disagreement highlights the tensions among various conservative factions and raises questions about the balance between the social and fiscal priorities of Republicans that has already become part of the debate in early-voting states like Iowa, where the state’s precinct caucuses are scheduled to open the nominating contest next Feb. 6.
The first in a series of candidate forums sponsored by the Family Leader, a social conservative advocacy group, started this week in Iowa. Mr. Pawlenty, the former governor of Minnesota, fielded questions about his opposition to abortion rights and same-sex marriage. Several prospective candidates have agreed in the coming months to participate in the sessions, which are sponsored by Bob Vander Plaats, a leading conservative in Iowa.
Mr. Vander Plaats said presidential contenders needed to address a spectrum of issues, including government spending and the deficit, same-sex marriage and abortion, if they hoped to find support among many conservative voters in Iowa.
“We’re looking for an authentic conservative that would be both social and fiscal,” Mr. Vander Plaats said. “It’s going to be a big part of the vetting process.”
http://www.nytimes.com/2011/02/09/us/politics/09republicans.html?_r=1&hp
Exceptionally Articulate
Foreign Policy Slate, Feb 8, 2011
Obama's eloquence fails to quiet charges that he does not believe in God or America.
By John Dickerson
Posted Monday, Feb. 7, 2011, at 7:30 PM ET
President Obama does not treat all conspiracy theories alike. He dismisses those who question where he was born, but he's unsettled by those who question whether he is born again. At the National Prayer Breakfast last week, he said his Christian faith has sustained him through his presidency—"all the more so," he said, "when Michelle and I hear our faith questioned."
Americans like their presidents to share their values, and religion is often a proxy for that connection. There has been at least some confusion about what Obama believes; in a recent poll, half of Americans said Obama holds religious values different from their own. Those who see the difference tend to view him unfavorably.
Of the three prayer-breakfast speeches the president has given since coming to office, this was his most personal talk on faith. As Time's Michael Scherer pointed out, in 2009, Obama used the first-person pronoun I 15 times in his prayer-breakfast remarks. He used the first-person pronoun 10 times in 2010. Last week, he used it 44 times. It was hard not to see the political balancing act: He was trying to give the religious charge just enough credence to smash it to pieces. It is a strategy Obama will need to perfect as the 2012 election approaches as he faces a similar charge—"he just doesn't believe in it"—on such issues as "American exceptionalism" and capitalism itself.
All of these issues represent inroads to a broader toxic argument against Obama that Hillary Clinton's chief strategist, Mark Penn, articulated in a strategy memo four years ago: "I cannot imagine America electing a president during a time of war who is not at his center fundamentally American in his thinking and in his values." Penn proposed targeting Obama's "lack of American roots" by wrapping Clinton almost literally in the flag. "Let's explicitly own 'American' in our programs, the speeches and the values. He doesn't. Make this a new American Century, the American Strategic Energy fund" What Penn wanted to do—without ever getting caught doing so—was raise the question in voter's minds: Is he one of us?
At its most corrosive, this set of issues promotes the idea that the president isn't simply supporting the "wrong" policies but has the "wrong" beliefs. But Penn failed (spectacularly), so how potent is this mix now?
It's big enough that the president had to address the religion element in his prayer breakfast. Sen. John McCain also addressed these issues when trying to make peace with Obama by defending him against the toughest conservative charge: "He is a patriot sincerely intent on using his time in office to advance our country's cause. I reject accusations that his policies and beliefs make him unworthy to lead America or opposed to its founding ideals."
The size of the exposure may also be determined by which GOP candidates try to feed it.
Is that what Mitt Romney was trying to do when he changed the subtitle of his book from No Apology: The Case for American Greatness to No Apology: Believe in America? It sounds right out of Penn's playbook. Romney's critique of the president is not just that Obama does not share American values but that Obama is intent on smothering them. Then again, as Romney allies say, maybe he is just trying to increase book sales.
When Newt Gingrich suggests the president "doesn't seem to have the kind of personality that allows normal Americans to get the rhythm of who he is," he is hitting on this theme. In his recent book he does it with a sledgehammer by suggesting Obama and the "secular-socialist machine" pose as great a threat to America as Nazi Germany or the Soviet Union. He has since moderated that charge but not its essential thrust. Even if he's not comparing the president to those two regimes, he's saying that he is so non-American that a person must stretch to find an analogy among the people who committed the greatest acts of human depravity.
On Monday, the president addressed the Chamber of Commerce in the latest of a series of steps aimed at rebutting the idea that he does not believe in American commerce. It is the easiest of these values charges to rebut because the president has some control over policies that might help or hurt business.
Opponents are likely to see Obama's prayer-breakfast speech or the American boosterism of his State of the Union address as insincere: He's just talking about these issues now because he's got an election coming. Such charges may have some power, especially if voters don't want to investigate them. But on the two big charges—that Obama doesn't believe in God, and doesn't believe in America—it's hard to make the case that the president has just discovered his faith or his voice in praising the American spirit.
Obama is a Christian—as he likes to put it, he has "a personal relationship with Jesus Christ." You don't have to hunt for proof. His embrace of Christ is a key point in his 1995 autobiography. He has spoken throughout his career about his faith. In 2004, he gave an extensive interview on the topic. In 2006, he scolded his own party for shutting out religion and scolded himself for not always boasting about the Christian roots of his values. A Politico story written in the first year of his presidency said he referred more to Jesus than George W. Bush did. (In the face of this, those who still want to judge Obama an unbeliever should go read their Matthew.)
It is also possible to find the same antecedents for the president's State of the Union address. When Obama spoke about America's history and the unique ability of Americans to shape their destiny, many saw it as an attempt to answer the charge that he did not believe in "American exceptionalism." That was certainly part of the pitch, but he didn't have to go to the library to hunt up the passages. Before Obama was facing the charge that he was not a believer in this brand of American bootstrapping, he was singing the identical song as a candidate.
To Obama's strongest critics, his view of "American exceptionalism" will not be sufficient. But they're not the audience for Obama's suasion. The voters who may need convincing are the ones in the middle of the electorate, the ones who believed he shared their values even when Sarah Palin said he was "palling around with terrorists." It's the message the president gave in his interview with Fox's Bill O'Reilly. "I'm the same guy."
http://www.slate.com/id/2283755/?from=rss
Obama's eloquence fails to quiet charges that he does not believe in God or America.
By John Dickerson
Posted Monday, Feb. 7, 2011, at 7:30 PM ET
President Obama does not treat all conspiracy theories alike. He dismisses those who question where he was born, but he's unsettled by those who question whether he is born again. At the National Prayer Breakfast last week, he said his Christian faith has sustained him through his presidency—"all the more so," he said, "when Michelle and I hear our faith questioned."
Americans like their presidents to share their values, and religion is often a proxy for that connection. There has been at least some confusion about what Obama believes; in a recent poll, half of Americans said Obama holds religious values different from their own. Those who see the difference tend to view him unfavorably.
Of the three prayer-breakfast speeches the president has given since coming to office, this was his most personal talk on faith. As Time's Michael Scherer pointed out, in 2009, Obama used the first-person pronoun I 15 times in his prayer-breakfast remarks. He used the first-person pronoun 10 times in 2010. Last week, he used it 44 times. It was hard not to see the political balancing act: He was trying to give the religious charge just enough credence to smash it to pieces. It is a strategy Obama will need to perfect as the 2012 election approaches as he faces a similar charge—"he just doesn't believe in it"—on such issues as "American exceptionalism" and capitalism itself.
All of these issues represent inroads to a broader toxic argument against Obama that Hillary Clinton's chief strategist, Mark Penn, articulated in a strategy memo four years ago: "I cannot imagine America electing a president during a time of war who is not at his center fundamentally American in his thinking and in his values." Penn proposed targeting Obama's "lack of American roots" by wrapping Clinton almost literally in the flag. "Let's explicitly own 'American' in our programs, the speeches and the values. He doesn't. Make this a new American Century, the American Strategic Energy fund" What Penn wanted to do—without ever getting caught doing so—was raise the question in voter's minds: Is he one of us?
At its most corrosive, this set of issues promotes the idea that the president isn't simply supporting the "wrong" policies but has the "wrong" beliefs. But Penn failed (spectacularly), so how potent is this mix now?
It's big enough that the president had to address the religion element in his prayer breakfast. Sen. John McCain also addressed these issues when trying to make peace with Obama by defending him against the toughest conservative charge: "He is a patriot sincerely intent on using his time in office to advance our country's cause. I reject accusations that his policies and beliefs make him unworthy to lead America or opposed to its founding ideals."
The size of the exposure may also be determined by which GOP candidates try to feed it.
Is that what Mitt Romney was trying to do when he changed the subtitle of his book from No Apology: The Case for American Greatness to No Apology: Believe in America? It sounds right out of Penn's playbook. Romney's critique of the president is not just that Obama does not share American values but that Obama is intent on smothering them. Then again, as Romney allies say, maybe he is just trying to increase book sales.
When Newt Gingrich suggests the president "doesn't seem to have the kind of personality that allows normal Americans to get the rhythm of who he is," he is hitting on this theme. In his recent book he does it with a sledgehammer by suggesting Obama and the "secular-socialist machine" pose as great a threat to America as Nazi Germany or the Soviet Union. He has since moderated that charge but not its essential thrust. Even if he's not comparing the president to those two regimes, he's saying that he is so non-American that a person must stretch to find an analogy among the people who committed the greatest acts of human depravity.
On Monday, the president addressed the Chamber of Commerce in the latest of a series of steps aimed at rebutting the idea that he does not believe in American commerce. It is the easiest of these values charges to rebut because the president has some control over policies that might help or hurt business.
Opponents are likely to see Obama's prayer-breakfast speech or the American boosterism of his State of the Union address as insincere: He's just talking about these issues now because he's got an election coming. Such charges may have some power, especially if voters don't want to investigate them. But on the two big charges—that Obama doesn't believe in God, and doesn't believe in America—it's hard to make the case that the president has just discovered his faith or his voice in praising the American spirit.
Obama is a Christian—as he likes to put it, he has "a personal relationship with Jesus Christ." You don't have to hunt for proof. His embrace of Christ is a key point in his 1995 autobiography. He has spoken throughout his career about his faith. In 2004, he gave an extensive interview on the topic. In 2006, he scolded his own party for shutting out religion and scolded himself for not always boasting about the Christian roots of his values. A Politico story written in the first year of his presidency said he referred more to Jesus than George W. Bush did. (In the face of this, those who still want to judge Obama an unbeliever should go read their Matthew.)
It is also possible to find the same antecedents for the president's State of the Union address. When Obama spoke about America's history and the unique ability of Americans to shape their destiny, many saw it as an attempt to answer the charge that he did not believe in "American exceptionalism." That was certainly part of the pitch, but he didn't have to go to the library to hunt up the passages. Before Obama was facing the charge that he was not a believer in this brand of American bootstrapping, he was singing the identical song as a candidate.
To Obama's strongest critics, his view of "American exceptionalism" will not be sufficient. But they're not the audience for Obama's suasion. The voters who may need convincing are the ones in the middle of the electorate, the ones who believed he shared their values even when Sarah Palin said he was "palling around with terrorists." It's the message the president gave in his interview with Fox's Bill O'Reilly. "I'm the same guy."
http://www.slate.com/id/2283755/?from=rss
Monday, February 7, 2011
Why We Can't Rule Out an Egyptian Reign of Terror
Foreign Policy, Feb 8, 2011
A historian's look at revolution and its discontents.
BY DAVID A. BELL | FEBRUARY 7, 2011
There are, of course, many different ways of categorizing historical revolutions. But for the purposes of understanding what is happening in Egypt -- and the challenges it may pose for the United States -- one simple, rough distinction may be especially useful. This is the distinction between revolutions that look more like 1688 and revolutions that look more like 1789. The first date refers to England's "Glorious Revolution," in which the Catholic, would-be absolute monarch James II was overthrown and replaced by the Protestant William and Mary and the English Parliament claimed powerful and enduring new forms of authority. The second is, of course, the date of the French Revolution, which began as an attempt to create a constitutional monarchy but ultimately led to the execution of King Louis XVI, the proclamation of the First French Republic, and the Reign of Terror.
A key feature of 1688-type revolutions is their relative brevity. They may be preceded by lengthy periods of discontent, agitation, protest, and even violence, but the revolutionary moment itself generally lasts for only a few months (as in 1688 itself), or even weeks or days. A regime reaches a point of crisis and falls. The consolidation of a new regime itself may well involve much more turmoil and bloodshed, and eventually entail considerable political and social change -- but these later events are not considered part of the revolution itself, and there is no sense of an ongoing revolutionary process. Men and women do not define themselves as active "revolutionaries" (in 1688, in fact, the English noun and adjective "revolutionary" did not yet exist -- it only came into frequent use after 1789).
Revolutions of the 1789 type are quite different. Their leaders and supporters see regime change as only the beginning of an arduous, ambitious process of political, social, and cultural transformation that may require years, even decades, to complete. For them, the revolution is not a discrete event, but an ongoing cause. They eagerly define themselves as "revolutionaries" and even speak of the "permanent revolution." Revolutions of this type generally have much stronger utopian tendencies than the others and more frequently lead to large-scale violence. They also tend to have ambitions that overflow national boundaries -- the local revolution becomes seen as just part of a process of worldwide emancipation. In some cases, revolutions of this type may be driven from the start by a self-consciously revolutionary party, committed to radical upheaval. In other cases (such as 1789 itself), it may seem to start off as a more limited event, only to change its character as particular groups grow frustrated with the results and the opposition they have encountered, and conclude that far broader, deeper forms of change are called for.
Historically, 1688-type revolutions have been much more common: France in 1830, Germany in 1918, China in 1911-12, and many of the revolutions of 1848 (of which most ended in failure). 1789-type revolutions, by contrast, have been relative historical rarities: above all, 1789 itself, Russia in 1917, China in 1949, Cuba in 1959. They are not, however, necessarily revolutions of the left. One could also include in this category the Nazi seizure of power in Germany (which Hitler termed a "National Revolution") and Iran in 1979. The American Revolution, it could be argued, represents something of a hybrid case -- closer to 1688, yet with important features of the other type, thanks to the long process of consolidation and contestation that followed independence.
In recent years, it seems as if the 1789 type of revolution has lost its appeal for most of the world. During the greatest series of political upheavals in recent times -- the collapse of communism -- most leaders of the victorious reform movements rejected the word "revolution" altogether. The Polish Solidarity leader Jacek Kuron went so far as to write in the summer of 1989, àpropos of the French Revolution's bicentennial, that Poland did not want a revolution because revolutions spill too much blood. Germans refer to the events of 1989 as the "Turning," not the "Revolution." It was, above all, in Czechoslovakia that the word "revolution" came to describe what happened in 1989, but paired with the word "velvet" to underscore the differences from the great revolutions of the past.
Of course, revolutions have hardly disappeared since 1989. But the recent wave of them across the world -- the Rose Revolution in Georgia, the Orange Revolution in Ukraine, the recent events in Tunisia -- all look much more like 1688 than 1789. They have been short, sharp affairs, centered on the fall of a regime. In none of these countries have we seen the development of an extended "revolutionary" process or party. And though some of these revolutions have triggered others, domino-style, as in 1848, they have not themselves been expansionary and proselytizing. As far as I know, there are no Tunisian revolutionaries directing events in Cairo.
The principal exception to the current pattern -- the one great contemporary revolution of the second type to remain an ongoing proposition today -- is Iran. Although it has been more than 30 years since the fall of the Shah, Iran's Islamic Republic is still a revolutionary regime in a way matched by few other states in the world today. Despite its considerable unpopularity with its own people, it has remained committed since 1979 to the enactment of radical, even utopian change, and not just inside its own borders. Organizations such as the Revolutionary Guard retain considerable importance.
Egypt, interestingly enough, experienced a revolution close to the 1789 type in its relatively recent history. The so-called Revolution of 1952 that overthrew the country's monarchy and brought Gamal Abdel Nasser to power ultimately involved a great deal more than regime change. Nasser had broad ambitions both for remaking Egyptian society and for taking his revolutionary movement beyond Egypt's own borders (most strikingly, in the creation of the short-lived United Arab Republic). Ironically, Hosni Mubarak spent much of his military career in the service of Nasser's revolutionary regime. But well before Mubarak came to power, following the assassination of Anwar Sadat in 1981, Egypt's revolutionary energies had largely dissipated.
The fundamental question being discussed by commentators at present is what shape a new Egyptian revolution might take, if Mubarak's regime falls and the military does not intervene. Will it come to a quick end with the establishment of a new government -- hopefully a democratic one -- or will a much more radical, long-lasting revolutionary process develop? In other words, will things look more like 1688 or 1789? Anxieties focus not on a resurgent Nasserism, of course, but rather on the Muslim Brotherhood and the possibility that Egypt may experience its own Islamic revolution, with unpredictable consequences, not only for the country itself but for the region and the world.
Against these anxieties, many commentators have been pointing to the lack of ingredients, at present, for such a turn of events. Cairo in 2011, they insist, is not Tehran in 1979. They argue that the crowds protesting Mubarak have called above all for democracy and expressed little enthusiasm for an Islamic Republic. They characterize the Muslim Brotherhood, despite its long and radical history, as a relatively ineffective organization that has recently moved in more moderate directions and that lacks a charismatic leader like Ayatollah Khomeini. In short, they are effectively arguing, the signs point to 1688, not to 1789.
This analysis may well be accurate. But the history of revolutions suggests that even if it is, the long-term outlook in Egypt is still a highly unstable one. This is not only because the furious events of the last two weeks are hard to predict, but because revolutions of the 1789 type do not always start out as such. Hardly anyone at the start of the French Revolution could have predicted the demise of the French monarchy and the Reign of Terror. There were no Jacobins present at the fall of the Bastille in 1789, only future Jacobins. France's turn to radicalism took place after the Bastille had been taken, within the revolutionary process itself -- between 1789 and 1793. Similarly, Russia's February Revolution of 1917 initially looked to most observers like 1688: a short, sharp crisis that led to the fall of a monarch, and the quick foundation of a constitutional regime. While Bolsheviks were already present, few observers foresaw the October Revolution that would bring Lenin to power.
Egypt probably does not face the prospect of an Islamic Revolution in the next few months. But if Mubarak falls and is replaced by a weak, unstable series of governments that cannot restore order or deliver serious social and economic reforms -- and thus quickly lose credibility and legitimacy among the population -- then a different, far more radical revolutionary movement may yet develop. And despite the current lack of a charismatic leader for such a movement, one could quickly emerge out of the torrent of events. In July 1789, Maximilien Robespierre and Georges Danton were unknown lawyers; Jean-Paul Marat an unknown doctor, known to most of his acquaintances as something of a crackpot. Within four years, they had emerged as leaders of the most radical revolution yet seen in history.
So the crucial point to keep in mind, as events in Egypt unfold, is that even in the best-case scenario -- Mubarak falls without further violence and is replaced by a seemingly stable, democratic, secular government -- the Egyptian Revolution of 2011 may still just be getting started. Its crucial moments may lie months, or even years, in the future. It is after Mubarak's fall that American support for Egypt's democratic forces will be most important. And the last thing anyone should do, if Egypt appears to complete a revolution this year that looks like 1688, is to breathe a sigh of relief. At the end of 2011, Mohamed ElBaradei may well be president of a democratic Egypt. But then, at the end of 1789, Louis XVI was still King of France.
http://www.foreignpolicy.com/articles/2011/02/07/why_we_cant_rule_out_an_egyptian_reign_of_terror
A historian's look at revolution and its discontents.
BY DAVID A. BELL | FEBRUARY 7, 2011
There are, of course, many different ways of categorizing historical revolutions. But for the purposes of understanding what is happening in Egypt -- and the challenges it may pose for the United States -- one simple, rough distinction may be especially useful. This is the distinction between revolutions that look more like 1688 and revolutions that look more like 1789. The first date refers to England's "Glorious Revolution," in which the Catholic, would-be absolute monarch James II was overthrown and replaced by the Protestant William and Mary and the English Parliament claimed powerful and enduring new forms of authority. The second is, of course, the date of the French Revolution, which began as an attempt to create a constitutional monarchy but ultimately led to the execution of King Louis XVI, the proclamation of the First French Republic, and the Reign of Terror.
A key feature of 1688-type revolutions is their relative brevity. They may be preceded by lengthy periods of discontent, agitation, protest, and even violence, but the revolutionary moment itself generally lasts for only a few months (as in 1688 itself), or even weeks or days. A regime reaches a point of crisis and falls. The consolidation of a new regime itself may well involve much more turmoil and bloodshed, and eventually entail considerable political and social change -- but these later events are not considered part of the revolution itself, and there is no sense of an ongoing revolutionary process. Men and women do not define themselves as active "revolutionaries" (in 1688, in fact, the English noun and adjective "revolutionary" did not yet exist -- it only came into frequent use after 1789).
Revolutions of the 1789 type are quite different. Their leaders and supporters see regime change as only the beginning of an arduous, ambitious process of political, social, and cultural transformation that may require years, even decades, to complete. For them, the revolution is not a discrete event, but an ongoing cause. They eagerly define themselves as "revolutionaries" and even speak of the "permanent revolution." Revolutions of this type generally have much stronger utopian tendencies than the others and more frequently lead to large-scale violence. They also tend to have ambitions that overflow national boundaries -- the local revolution becomes seen as just part of a process of worldwide emancipation. In some cases, revolutions of this type may be driven from the start by a self-consciously revolutionary party, committed to radical upheaval. In other cases (such as 1789 itself), it may seem to start off as a more limited event, only to change its character as particular groups grow frustrated with the results and the opposition they have encountered, and conclude that far broader, deeper forms of change are called for.
Historically, 1688-type revolutions have been much more common: France in 1830, Germany in 1918, China in 1911-12, and many of the revolutions of 1848 (of which most ended in failure). 1789-type revolutions, by contrast, have been relative historical rarities: above all, 1789 itself, Russia in 1917, China in 1949, Cuba in 1959. They are not, however, necessarily revolutions of the left. One could also include in this category the Nazi seizure of power in Germany (which Hitler termed a "National Revolution") and Iran in 1979. The American Revolution, it could be argued, represents something of a hybrid case -- closer to 1688, yet with important features of the other type, thanks to the long process of consolidation and contestation that followed independence.
In recent years, it seems as if the 1789 type of revolution has lost its appeal for most of the world. During the greatest series of political upheavals in recent times -- the collapse of communism -- most leaders of the victorious reform movements rejected the word "revolution" altogether. The Polish Solidarity leader Jacek Kuron went so far as to write in the summer of 1989, àpropos of the French Revolution's bicentennial, that Poland did not want a revolution because revolutions spill too much blood. Germans refer to the events of 1989 as the "Turning," not the "Revolution." It was, above all, in Czechoslovakia that the word "revolution" came to describe what happened in 1989, but paired with the word "velvet" to underscore the differences from the great revolutions of the past.
Of course, revolutions have hardly disappeared since 1989. But the recent wave of them across the world -- the Rose Revolution in Georgia, the Orange Revolution in Ukraine, the recent events in Tunisia -- all look much more like 1688 than 1789. They have been short, sharp affairs, centered on the fall of a regime. In none of these countries have we seen the development of an extended "revolutionary" process or party. And though some of these revolutions have triggered others, domino-style, as in 1848, they have not themselves been expansionary and proselytizing. As far as I know, there are no Tunisian revolutionaries directing events in Cairo.
The principal exception to the current pattern -- the one great contemporary revolution of the second type to remain an ongoing proposition today -- is Iran. Although it has been more than 30 years since the fall of the Shah, Iran's Islamic Republic is still a revolutionary regime in a way matched by few other states in the world today. Despite its considerable unpopularity with its own people, it has remained committed since 1979 to the enactment of radical, even utopian change, and not just inside its own borders. Organizations such as the Revolutionary Guard retain considerable importance.
Egypt, interestingly enough, experienced a revolution close to the 1789 type in its relatively recent history. The so-called Revolution of 1952 that overthrew the country's monarchy and brought Gamal Abdel Nasser to power ultimately involved a great deal more than regime change. Nasser had broad ambitions both for remaking Egyptian society and for taking his revolutionary movement beyond Egypt's own borders (most strikingly, in the creation of the short-lived United Arab Republic). Ironically, Hosni Mubarak spent much of his military career in the service of Nasser's revolutionary regime. But well before Mubarak came to power, following the assassination of Anwar Sadat in 1981, Egypt's revolutionary energies had largely dissipated.
The fundamental question being discussed by commentators at present is what shape a new Egyptian revolution might take, if Mubarak's regime falls and the military does not intervene. Will it come to a quick end with the establishment of a new government -- hopefully a democratic one -- or will a much more radical, long-lasting revolutionary process develop? In other words, will things look more like 1688 or 1789? Anxieties focus not on a resurgent Nasserism, of course, but rather on the Muslim Brotherhood and the possibility that Egypt may experience its own Islamic revolution, with unpredictable consequences, not only for the country itself but for the region and the world.
Against these anxieties, many commentators have been pointing to the lack of ingredients, at present, for such a turn of events. Cairo in 2011, they insist, is not Tehran in 1979. They argue that the crowds protesting Mubarak have called above all for democracy and expressed little enthusiasm for an Islamic Republic. They characterize the Muslim Brotherhood, despite its long and radical history, as a relatively ineffective organization that has recently moved in more moderate directions and that lacks a charismatic leader like Ayatollah Khomeini. In short, they are effectively arguing, the signs point to 1688, not to 1789.
This analysis may well be accurate. But the history of revolutions suggests that even if it is, the long-term outlook in Egypt is still a highly unstable one. This is not only because the furious events of the last two weeks are hard to predict, but because revolutions of the 1789 type do not always start out as such. Hardly anyone at the start of the French Revolution could have predicted the demise of the French monarchy and the Reign of Terror. There were no Jacobins present at the fall of the Bastille in 1789, only future Jacobins. France's turn to radicalism took place after the Bastille had been taken, within the revolutionary process itself -- between 1789 and 1793. Similarly, Russia's February Revolution of 1917 initially looked to most observers like 1688: a short, sharp crisis that led to the fall of a monarch, and the quick foundation of a constitutional regime. While Bolsheviks were already present, few observers foresaw the October Revolution that would bring Lenin to power.
Egypt probably does not face the prospect of an Islamic Revolution in the next few months. But if Mubarak falls and is replaced by a weak, unstable series of governments that cannot restore order or deliver serious social and economic reforms -- and thus quickly lose credibility and legitimacy among the population -- then a different, far more radical revolutionary movement may yet develop. And despite the current lack of a charismatic leader for such a movement, one could quickly emerge out of the torrent of events. In July 1789, Maximilien Robespierre and Georges Danton were unknown lawyers; Jean-Paul Marat an unknown doctor, known to most of his acquaintances as something of a crackpot. Within four years, they had emerged as leaders of the most radical revolution yet seen in history.
So the crucial point to keep in mind, as events in Egypt unfold, is that even in the best-case scenario -- Mubarak falls without further violence and is replaced by a seemingly stable, democratic, secular government -- the Egyptian Revolution of 2011 may still just be getting started. Its crucial moments may lie months, or even years, in the future. It is after Mubarak's fall that American support for Egypt's democratic forces will be most important. And the last thing anyone should do, if Egypt appears to complete a revolution this year that looks like 1688, is to breathe a sigh of relief. At the end of 2011, Mohamed ElBaradei may well be president of a democratic Egypt. But then, at the end of 1789, Louis XVI was still King of France.
http://www.foreignpolicy.com/articles/2011/02/07/why_we_cant_rule_out_an_egyptian_reign_of_terror
Egypt Uprising
After a year of keeping the weblong inactive, now the Egyptian Revolution has inspired me to start writing. Today I was looking at New York Times. In the Room for Debate, I found these remarks interesting.
Egypt Is Not Iran
February 7, 2011
Michael Rubin is a resident scholar at the American Enterprise Institute.
Behind the Obama administration’s concern over legalism, many current and former officials worry that any withdrawal of support for Egyptian President Mubarak will reverberate through the region much as did President Carter’s abandonment of the Shah of Iran.
A legalistic U.S. approach is no way to promote democratic change.
The two situations are not analogous, however. Egypt has been an ally in name only. When Vice President Cheney called Mubarak a good friend and a U.S. ally, it is telling that his example of Mubarak’s friendship — Egyptian assistance during the liberation of Kuwait — is two decades old. He omitted that Mubarak held out for $14 billion in debt forgiveness before he chose sides.
As for the shah, Iran had been a loyal ally during the cold war when the stakes were higher. While the shah’s fall harmed American national security interests, what occurred next compounded the damage: Desperate to ingratiate himself with revolutionary students, President Carter was willing to sacrifice the shah’s life. He not only sought to force the shah to leave American soil for Panama, but he quietly encouraged Panamanian authorities to send the shah back to Iran before the deposed monarch could travel on to Egypt. Thankfully, they did not. The problem with Carter’s approach was not the shah’s fall, but White House dithering in its aftermath.
So long as Mubarak remains in power, the most radical elements will use his presence as an irritant against which to rally. If Obama and Secretary Clinton try to take a legalistic approach now, they will alienate the protesters. After all, Mubarak’s behavior was little grounded in Egyptian constitutionalism. Instead they should be proactive: They should support establishment of a technocratic transitional government, use their soapbox to help it make the necessary legal changes to ensure a smooth election according to a set time line, and then welcome Egypt’s new democratic order.
Cautionary Lessons from Iran and Lebanon
Updated February 7, 2011, 06:44 PMDavid Makovsky is the Ziegler Distinguished Fellow and the director of the Washington Institute for Near East Policy project on the Middle East Peace Process. He is the co-author with Dennis Ross of “Myths, Illusions and Peace: Finding a New Direction for America in the Middle East” and the author of "Imagining a Border."
President Obama is walking a tightrope: On the one hand, he aims to support American democratic values in non-democratic states. On the other hand, he and his advisers must realize that democratic revolutions in the Middle East have all too often been subverted by groups that use liberal means to reach illiberal ends.
Contemporary history teaches us to be cautious when examining the intersection of Islamic parties and revolutions.
The Islamists have demonstrated that they are potent not because they are a majority, but because they are a determined and disciplined minority.
In 1979, people of all political inclinations took to the streets in massive demonstrations to oust the Shah from Tehran. Liberals, trade unionists, and Communists joined hands with Islamists. Yet, it was not long before the Islamist-dominated Iranian parliament impeached the new moderate Iranian president Bani Sadr and the Revolutionary Guards seized his office. In the years that followed, Islamists proceeded to discard civil liberties, including imprisoning the masses who protested the sham elections of June 2009.
In 2005, the world celebrated the “Cedar Revolution” in Lebanon. It is widely believed that Hezbollah was behind the political assassination of beloved former Lebanese Prime Minister Rafik Hariri in February 2005, which triggered the uprising.
In May 2008, its militia coerced the Druze — a key pillar of the Cedar Revolution — to rescind their support for Saad Hariri. Finally, Hezbollah toppled the Lebanese government last month in opposition to the international tribunal investigating Rafik Hariri’s assassination.
Likewise, when people say that the U.S. need not worry about the Egypt ‘s Muslim Brotherhood because they are supported by less than 30 percent of the public, they miss the point. The Islamists have demonstrated that they are potent not because they are a majority, but because they are a determined and disciplined minority.
They do not play by democratic rules. Both in the case of Hezbollah and Hamas, they created their own Iran-backed independent militias that exploit the fragility of the state. The Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas accused Hamas, which was in a power sharing government with Abbas, of a coup when it expelled the authority ’s security forces from Gaza in June 2007.
We cannot be certain whether the Muslim Brotherhood will follow these models. (Saying you are against violence as the Brotherhood says when they have the Egyptian security state on top of them does not count for much.) Given the complexity of the issue, the U.S. would do well to couple its support for democratic values with quiet support for Egyptian military efforts to reach out to assorted democratic forces in the opposition. Let those Egyptian forces negotiate a plan for constitutional change that nobody can charge is “made in the U.S.A .”
Stop Fixating on Mubarak
Updated February 7, 2011, 11:39 PM
Lydia Khalil is a board member of the Project on Middle East Democracy and a non-resident fellow at the Australian Strategic Policy Institute.
Last week, Robert Gibbs was asked to clarify what President Obama meant when he said "an orderly transition must begin now." "Now means yesterday," Gibbs replied. Fast forward a few days and the administration's special emissary to Egypt, Frank Wisner, says, "President Mubarak's role remains extremely critical in the days ahead."
The U.S. has a habit of reducing a complicated, dynamic situation to the actions and fate of one strongman.
The Obama administration's mixed messaging is not only reflective of the uncertainty of the situation as both Egypt and Washington grapple with what's next, but it is symptomatic of the United States' long standing foreign policy contradictions in the Middle East. It reflects the unsavory habit of the U.S. foreign policy establishment to focus on the short term rather than the long term and to reduce a complicated, dynamic situation to the actions and fate of one strongman.
By fixating on the terms of Mubarak's departure, the Obama administration is missing the forest for the trees. Though the U.S. has come out in support of political reform and a democratic transition, it is still framing the debate in terms of the fate of one person. Egypt's transition to democracy is about much more than whether Mubarak stays on until September or leaves right away. Regardless of whether the United States pushes for his ouster immediately or argues that a transition period is needed, it is not addressing the fundamental concerns of the Egyptian opposition and risks alienating its future partners.
The administration needs to understand what is behind the protesters call for Mubarak's ouster. The calls for Mubarak's immediate removal are fundamentally an emotive response to the suffering and stagnation that most Egyptians experienced under his regime. There is also fear that the longer Mubarak is allowed to stay, the greater the chances he will try to reverse the momentum against him.
The protesters don't want to replace Mubarak with another one of his cronies or return to military rule. At the same time, Egyptians don't want chaos and are wary of the consequences of rapid change. They want responsive governmental institutions, a decent education for their children, job opportunities, and the creation of an Egyptian society that restores dignity and allows for meaningful participation.
The Obama administration needs to concentrate on these fundamental demands, do what it can to bolster the secular opposition and assist in initiating institutional and constitutional reform. It must shift the conversation away from Mubarak's immediate future to what it plans to do to help Egypt become a stable and representative government responsive to the needs of its people.
Egypt Is Not Iran
February 7, 2011
Michael Rubin is a resident scholar at the American Enterprise Institute.
Behind the Obama administration’s concern over legalism, many current and former officials worry that any withdrawal of support for Egyptian President Mubarak will reverberate through the region much as did President Carter’s abandonment of the Shah of Iran.
A legalistic U.S. approach is no way to promote democratic change.
The two situations are not analogous, however. Egypt has been an ally in name only. When Vice President Cheney called Mubarak a good friend and a U.S. ally, it is telling that his example of Mubarak’s friendship — Egyptian assistance during the liberation of Kuwait — is two decades old. He omitted that Mubarak held out for $14 billion in debt forgiveness before he chose sides.
As for the shah, Iran had been a loyal ally during the cold war when the stakes were higher. While the shah’s fall harmed American national security interests, what occurred next compounded the damage: Desperate to ingratiate himself with revolutionary students, President Carter was willing to sacrifice the shah’s life. He not only sought to force the shah to leave American soil for Panama, but he quietly encouraged Panamanian authorities to send the shah back to Iran before the deposed monarch could travel on to Egypt. Thankfully, they did not. The problem with Carter’s approach was not the shah’s fall, but White House dithering in its aftermath.
So long as Mubarak remains in power, the most radical elements will use his presence as an irritant against which to rally. If Obama and Secretary Clinton try to take a legalistic approach now, they will alienate the protesters. After all, Mubarak’s behavior was little grounded in Egyptian constitutionalism. Instead they should be proactive: They should support establishment of a technocratic transitional government, use their soapbox to help it make the necessary legal changes to ensure a smooth election according to a set time line, and then welcome Egypt’s new democratic order.
Cautionary Lessons from Iran and Lebanon
Updated February 7, 2011, 06:44 PMDavid Makovsky is the Ziegler Distinguished Fellow and the director of the Washington Institute for Near East Policy project on the Middle East Peace Process. He is the co-author with Dennis Ross of “Myths, Illusions and Peace: Finding a New Direction for America in the Middle East” and the author of "Imagining a Border."
President Obama is walking a tightrope: On the one hand, he aims to support American democratic values in non-democratic states. On the other hand, he and his advisers must realize that democratic revolutions in the Middle East have all too often been subverted by groups that use liberal means to reach illiberal ends.
Contemporary history teaches us to be cautious when examining the intersection of Islamic parties and revolutions.
The Islamists have demonstrated that they are potent not because they are a majority, but because they are a determined and disciplined minority.
In 1979, people of all political inclinations took to the streets in massive demonstrations to oust the Shah from Tehran. Liberals, trade unionists, and Communists joined hands with Islamists. Yet, it was not long before the Islamist-dominated Iranian parliament impeached the new moderate Iranian president Bani Sadr and the Revolutionary Guards seized his office. In the years that followed, Islamists proceeded to discard civil liberties, including imprisoning the masses who protested the sham elections of June 2009.
In 2005, the world celebrated the “Cedar Revolution” in Lebanon. It is widely believed that Hezbollah was behind the political assassination of beloved former Lebanese Prime Minister Rafik Hariri in February 2005, which triggered the uprising.
In May 2008, its militia coerced the Druze — a key pillar of the Cedar Revolution — to rescind their support for Saad Hariri. Finally, Hezbollah toppled the Lebanese government last month in opposition to the international tribunal investigating Rafik Hariri’s assassination.
Likewise, when people say that the U.S. need not worry about the Egypt ‘s Muslim Brotherhood because they are supported by less than 30 percent of the public, they miss the point. The Islamists have demonstrated that they are potent not because they are a majority, but because they are a determined and disciplined minority.
They do not play by democratic rules. Both in the case of Hezbollah and Hamas, they created their own Iran-backed independent militias that exploit the fragility of the state. The Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas accused Hamas, which was in a power sharing government with Abbas, of a coup when it expelled the authority ’s security forces from Gaza in June 2007.
We cannot be certain whether the Muslim Brotherhood will follow these models. (Saying you are against violence as the Brotherhood says when they have the Egyptian security state on top of them does not count for much.) Given the complexity of the issue, the U.S. would do well to couple its support for democratic values with quiet support for Egyptian military efforts to reach out to assorted democratic forces in the opposition. Let those Egyptian forces negotiate a plan for constitutional change that nobody can charge is “made in the U.S.A .”
Stop Fixating on Mubarak
Updated February 7, 2011, 11:39 PM
Lydia Khalil is a board member of the Project on Middle East Democracy and a non-resident fellow at the Australian Strategic Policy Institute.
Last week, Robert Gibbs was asked to clarify what President Obama meant when he said "an orderly transition must begin now." "Now means yesterday," Gibbs replied. Fast forward a few days and the administration's special emissary to Egypt, Frank Wisner, says, "President Mubarak's role remains extremely critical in the days ahead."
The U.S. has a habit of reducing a complicated, dynamic situation to the actions and fate of one strongman.
The Obama administration's mixed messaging is not only reflective of the uncertainty of the situation as both Egypt and Washington grapple with what's next, but it is symptomatic of the United States' long standing foreign policy contradictions in the Middle East. It reflects the unsavory habit of the U.S. foreign policy establishment to focus on the short term rather than the long term and to reduce a complicated, dynamic situation to the actions and fate of one strongman.
By fixating on the terms of Mubarak's departure, the Obama administration is missing the forest for the trees. Though the U.S. has come out in support of political reform and a democratic transition, it is still framing the debate in terms of the fate of one person. Egypt's transition to democracy is about much more than whether Mubarak stays on until September or leaves right away. Regardless of whether the United States pushes for his ouster immediately or argues that a transition period is needed, it is not addressing the fundamental concerns of the Egyptian opposition and risks alienating its future partners.
The administration needs to understand what is behind the protesters call for Mubarak's ouster. The calls for Mubarak's immediate removal are fundamentally an emotive response to the suffering and stagnation that most Egyptians experienced under his regime. There is also fear that the longer Mubarak is allowed to stay, the greater the chances he will try to reverse the momentum against him.
The protesters don't want to replace Mubarak with another one of his cronies or return to military rule. At the same time, Egyptians don't want chaos and are wary of the consequences of rapid change. They want responsive governmental institutions, a decent education for their children, job opportunities, and the creation of an Egyptian society that restores dignity and allows for meaningful participation.
The Obama administration needs to concentrate on these fundamental demands, do what it can to bolster the secular opposition and assist in initiating institutional and constitutional reform. It must shift the conversation away from Mubarak's immediate future to what it plans to do to help Egypt become a stable and representative government responsive to the needs of its people.
Monday, December 21, 2009
America in minds

People usually have a mental image of the things they hear. We form pictures of different things in our minds. Sometimes, there are images formed in our minds which may not be real. We may have pre-conceived ideas about different things. In psychology, the term, schema refers to a structure of pre-conceived ideas formed in the mind. These pre-conceived ideas may be different from the reality. One of the examples of schemata is stereotyping. Stereotypes have always been with us and few people really try to stay away from stereotypes. In Iran, we do see stereotypes about people of different ethnic groups which may not be really true but those stereotypes seem to be an indelible picture formed in the minds of people. When it comes to America, I think there are some stereotypes about America in Iran just like the stereotypes about Iran which exist in other parts of world such as the U.S. In Iran, we are only dealing with America’s government and its foreign policy but we do not know much about American people. So, we may think that American people also possess the characteristics of their government officials and they do the things that their government does. Some people may think that Americans are violent oppressors and do not have kindness and sympathy towards other people or may not care about others. However, in reality this is not true and we cannot judge people with a set of pre-conceived ideas that we have about them. The same thing exists in the west and in America about Iran. People have negative views about Iran and its people because of the way Iran and Islam are shown to them through the media. Thus, we have to be careful of stereotypes and do not judge people or countries by a set of fixed ideas formed in our minds which may not be true.
Thursday, December 10, 2009
How is President Obama doing?

In order to find out how well a politician performs, we have to consider public opinion. In a democratic system, it’s important to find out the percentage of people approving or disapproving of the policies of the government. In America, public opinion polls are conducted quite frequently to seek people’s opinions regarding different issues. The same thing has happened with the President of Change, Mr. Barack Obama. Obama became the president of the United States while people were unhappy with many things in the country and wanted a change for the better. President Obama had to deal with big issues like economic recession, health care, and the war in Afghanistan. Now the first year of his office has passed and this is how people have rated his performance.
Although, people in general have a favorable view of President Obama, his job approval rating has declined. According to CNN/Opinion Research poll conducted on Dec. 2-3, Obama’s approval rating has fallen from 55 percent in mid-November to 48 percent and the biggest drop has come from non-college-educated white voters. As the poll director believes, this may show that unemployment has caused president’s approval rating to fall. People have also given their opinions regarding different issues like economy, the War in Afghanistan and health care. According to Marist Poll, a majority of registered voters, 51 percent, disapprove of Obama’s handling of the economy. However, 65 percent of the people believe that today’s economic situation is the inheritance of President Bush. Nonetheless, most of the polls reveal that many people are very or somewhat dissatisfied with the present state of the economy. Another important issue is the War in Afghanistan. Polls conducted up to early November showed that the majority of people were against sending more troops to Afghanistan. However, after President’s speech explaining the strategies to deploy 30,000 troops to Afghanistan, the number of people approving of his plan is growing. When it comes to health care, it is not so easy to compare the results of different polls since the questions asked differ from one poll to another. Some polls may have tried to measure people’s support or opposition to health care reform overall, while some others may have asked questions regarding different parts of the health care plan. However, there seems to be an agreement on the point that there is satisfaction among the majority of people who have health coverage and most of them believe that a change in the health care system will not improve their situation or may even make it worse. So according to Gallup, it seems that “the public does not feel a strong sense of urgency about passing health care reform.” While president Obama has been working hard to pass his health care reform plan, Americans seem to be more concerned about the problems of economy and employment.
As we can see, people are constantly being asked about their opinion regarding the overall performance of the president and the way he handles different issues. This is something we do not have in Iran. There are no polls conducted to reflect people’s opinion regarding the performance of the President and his cabinet. Now, the issue of subsidies is what many people are worried about but we see no polls measuring people’s support or position to the government plan. Although, media try to reflect public opinion, I think we need to have proper statistics of public opinion on different issues. This way, I believe, people feel that it is important for the officials to find out their opinion regarding different issues.
* taken from http://www.politicsdaily.com
Wednesday, December 9, 2009
Poverty is the gift of the New World, my child!

Last week I was reviewing a book named America Unequal. This book focuses on the problems of poverty and income inequality in the U.S. Today, I saw the news about the poverty of illegal immigrants in the U.S. and that the U.S. born kids of illegal immigrants are more likely to face poverty than others. According to the book I was reading ethnic minorities have experienced more poverty than the white majority in the U.S. and the passage of time has not only reduced the poverty in the U.S. but also widened the gap between the rich and the poor. Today, America is facing another problem and that is the growing number of illegal immigrants from different parts of the world especially from Mexico and Central America. Hispanic people come to the land of dreams hoping to find better opportunities. They may succeed but many of them do face a lot of difficulties making both ends meet. Although the U.S. born children of these illegal immigrants can get all the benefits provided to U.S. citizens, many parents are reluctant to apply for such benefits due to the fear of being asked to provide documentations. Many of these illegal immigrants are not highly educated and it’s harder for them to climb up the job ladder due to their immigration status. As a result, their children are more prone to poverty than the children of legal immigrants or native parents. These children are also afraid of losing their parents since their parents can be deported any time while they can remain in the U.S as American citizens. Despite all these difficulties, illegal immigrants believe that the situation of their children is much better in the U.S. than their home country.
I suppose a similar problem exists here in Iran. There are many Afghan immigrants in Iran both legal and illegal. Many of the illegal immigrants get involved in crimes in order to overcome their poverty and this endangers our security. While America has had a long experience of dealing with immigrants, our country has recently been involved with this issue. As the numbers of illegal immigrants to both Iran and U.S. are on the rise, it seems that new policies are needed to deal with this problem especially in Iran.
Book Review

Co-author Book Review
Marzieh Javadi Arjmand, Ata Karimnejad
America Unequal
Authors: Danziger, Sheldon / Gottschalk, Peter
Year: 1995
Publisher: Russell Sage Foundation
ISBN: 0-674-01811-7
About the Authors:
Dr. Danziger is a research professor and director of National Poverty Center, Research and Training Program on Poverty and Public Policy in the University of Michigan. His area of interest includes trends in poverty and equality and the effects of economic and demographic changes, government social programs and disadvantaged groups. His recent publications are:
Cancian, Maria, and Sheldon H. Danziger. 2009. Changing Poverty, Changing Policies. Russell Sage. Abstract. Publisher Link .
Danziger, Sheldon H., and Cecilia Elena Rouse. 2007. The Price of Independence: The Economics of Early Adulthood. New York: Russell Sage Foundation. Abstract.
Blank, Rebecca M., Sheldon H. Danziger, and Robert F. Schoeni. 2006. Working and Poor: How Economic and Policy Changes Are Affecting Low-Wage Workers. New York: Russell Sage Foundation. Abstract.
Danziger, Sheldon H., and Peter Gottschalk. 2004. Diverging Fortunes: Trends in Poverty and Inequality. Russell Sage Foundation and Population Reference Bureau. Abstract.
Danziger, Sheldon H., and Robert Haveman. 2002. Understanding Poverty. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press. Abstract.
Danziger, Sheldon H., and Ann Chih Lin. 2000. Coping With Poverty: The Social Contexts of Neighborhood, Work and Family in the African-American Community. Ann Arbor, MI: University of Michigan Press. Abstract.
Danziger, Sheldon H., and Jane Wadfogel. 2000. Securing the Future: Investing in Children from Birth to College. New York: Russell Sage. Abstract.
Farley, Reynolds, Sheldon H. Danziger, and Harry J. Holzer. 2000. Detroit Divided. Russell Sage. Abstract.
Danziger, Sheldon H. 1999. Economic Conditions and Welfare Reform. Kalamazoo, MI: Upjohn Institute. Abstract.
Journal Articles:
Danziger, Sheldon H., Davis, M.M., S. Orzol, and H.A. Pollack. 2008. "Health insurance and access to care among welfare leavers." Inquiry-the Journal of Health Care Organization Provision and Financing, 45(2): 184-197. Worldcat.
Dr. Peter Gottschalk, the co-author of this book is a senior research affiliate at National Poverty Center, University of Michigan. He is also research affiliate at the Institute for Research on Poverty, University of Wisconsin and research associate at the Center for Retirement Research, Boston College. His research interest includes labor economics and human resource economics.
Review and Analysis:
This book, America Unequal (1995), shows us how “American dream” has not come true, as the writer contends that Americans have had hard “economic times” since 1970s. Before this turning point, people were highly optimistic about their children’s future, but the way history wove the threads of events showed us that poverty and inequality of incomes increased.
After the disastrous Second World War, there came an economic boom during which most of the people were employed with remarkable wages; however, this pattern reversed after the 1970s.
The author places his diagnosis on the issues regarding technological advances, globalization of markets, and structural changes in the body of economic system which put a division between low-skilled and high-skilled workers. He believes that the Republican’s “Contract with America” compounded the problem and helped widen the gap between privileged citizens and those who are not.
According to Danziger and Gottschalk, measures taken by the government, in order to combat the existing economic situation, have not been successful, thus the way, Danziger says, to get over the devastating outcomes of the above mentioned issues is “to adjust public and private sectors to changes in economic environment.”
Then a series of diverse plans and policies were introduced during 1960s-1990s. The second chapter centers on the policies adopted in the last four decades to reduce poverty. “War on Poverty” being the major plan of the era, introduced by President Johnson during 1960s, is originated form two strategies which have been dominant since the 1930s: The income transfers and employment programs. Johnson’s inefficient plan faced failure because, as some critics note, of the “throwing money at the problem” strategy. The last of the introduced policies were that of Clinton’s emphasizing antipoverty programs which did not achieve the desired efficacy due to objections constantly put forward by a Republican majority Congress which, at that time, had its mind locked on “government-is-the-problem” view of Reagan administration.
Danziger and Gottschalk go another step further by providing the readers with chapters revolving around arithmetical/statistical information and analyses trying to approach the problems of society in a more new-fashioned technical way. According to Danziger, there are multiple deficiencies regarding the measurement of family income methods such as: they seem to be ignorant of the rapid population growth rate, and they do not consider “decline in average family size.”
Another interesting situation is disclosed by the authors which is the delicate paradox in the 1980s economic situation. Despite the increase in family income, the inequality did not decrease. Based on the wrong assumptions, Danziger believes, the government of the post 1983 could not remove the problem of income inequality.
Regarding the different demographic groups categorized by age, sex, race and ethnicity, findings indicate that they were exposed to identical economic parameters although their standards of living drastically differed from one another. There’s a difference in standards of living comparing two periods as we distinguish as old and new. In the old one, young adults earned more than the old which turned out to be quite the opposite in the following period. Moreover, a fixed pattern in income inequality came into being which put the whites over other ethnic groups, married couples over single-parent headed families.
Demographic and economic factors are introduced as reasons for poverty remaining high. The period between 1949- 1969, also known as baby boom period, is being held as an important demographic factor, in this regard. Other alterations such as slow income growth, rising inequality and more demographic changes, which have taken place during 1973- 1991, are again among culprits leading to later poverty. The authors of this book; however, call out a number of changes regarding economic factors which are believed to have contributed to the status quo of poverty. Changes in distribution of earnings of family heads, changes in the distribution of earnings of other family members, and changes in the distribution of all sources of income are among them.
There is another perspective concerning the economic history of the United States; that is to bring into focus the changes in the labor market. Labor market has been flexible toward some changes throughout its recent past. First of them is considered to be because of inequality in men’s earnings during 1973- 1991. The other is technological changes and finally the ultimate transition in the industrial market into service sector. These changes, consequently, are to leave footsteps in individuals’ lives. So many people lost their jobs in manufacturing industry and had to choose one among low wage jobs in service sector.
Results from so many surveys have conveyed that from 1980s onward the trend in equality of earnings has been stable but inequality, both inequality between groups and inequality within groups, has not showed signs of falling.
Regarding the increase of the inequality of earnings, Danziger and Gottschalk contend: “mechanisms are important; if we understand the casual mechanisms, we could predict whether inequality would continue to increase or whether it would return to the level of the 1970s. An understanding of the causes of the slow growth and increased inequality of earnings can also inform public policy.”
There is an economic theory on inequality of earning which indicates that once there is a competition in any market place, a following allocation of resources will be inevitable and therefore technological advancement will be encouraged. However, obviously efficiency does not equal to equity. “There is nothing about a market economy that ensures that a rising standard of living will be accompanied by reduced inequality.”
Inequality of earnings seems to have enjoyed a remarkable increase in the 1980s which was triggered by employers hiring more educated workers.
The authors allocate the final chapter of this book, America Unequal, to antipoverty plans undergone in American History. The discussion continues giving a taste of what has been carried out to narrow down, or even terminate, the existing gap between the ever-growing rich and the poor. There have been attempts in this dimension starting from the declaration of “War on Poverty” to 1988 family Support Act and so on. But nothing ever done seemed to have been able to create dramatic changes in the so called domestic economic affairs.
"The planners of the ‘War on Poverty’ expected that the combination of rapid economic growth and antipoverty policies would raise the incomes of those families who were still outside the economic mainstream” and would help raise the people at the bottom of the income scale to the top and therefore put an end to inequality, but the oil embargo of the 1973 and the following three economic recessions over nine years made it a mere dream.
Sheldon H. Danziger and Peter Gottschalk in their book America Unequal try to get an important message across; the fact that economic forces, or one might incline to say determinism, have put frames to the dream of millions of Americans. This book, through so many graphs and scientific analyses depicts why is it that even major economic programs are impotent of making a drastic improvement addressing all the existing classes in the American society.
Tuesday, November 24, 2009
Friendship of faiths in America

America is a religiously as well as ethnically diverse country. Although the majority of people are Christians, we do see many other religions as well. How far are American people religious tolerant? Does inter-faith dailogue promote religious tolerance? Well, first we need to know the meaning of inter-faith diologue. “The terms interfaith or interfaith dialogue refer to cooperative and positive interaction between people of different religious traditions (i.e., "faiths") and spiritual or humanistic beliefs, at both the individual and institutional level with the aim of deriving a common ground in belief through a concentration on similarities between faiths, understanding of values, and commitment to the world.”[1]
Inter-faith diologue is not something new. In fact it has existed since long time ago. Now, we see that in America the inter-faith dialogue between three clergymen has made them good friends of each other
The three Muslim, Christian and Jewish clergymen have tried to show people that people believing in different religions can be good friends.

All three clergymen are in the liberal wing of their respective faiths. Mr. Mackenzie, 65, is a minister in the United Church of Christ, and recently retired from leading a large congregation, the University Congregational U.C.C., in Seattle. As a young man, he taught in Lebanon. Rabbi Falcon, 67, is a Reform rabbi with a doctorate in clinical psychology who founded synagogues in Los Angeles and Seattle that meld meditation with Jewish tradition. Sheik Rahman, 59, is a Sufi; a path of Islam focused more on spiritual wisdom than strict ritual. He is the son of a diplomat from Bangladesh. He co-founded an unusual mixed-faith congregation in Seattle, the Interfaith Community Church. Today, these three friends first went to an Indian restaurant in Nashville and then attended a Presbyterian church where they delivered speeches to 250 people about how they had wrestled with their religious differences and emerged as friends. These three clergymen call themselves “interfaith amigos”. They said that they had managed to establish friendly relationships by running straight at their conflicts and not avoiding them. “One of the problems in the past with interfaith dialogue is we’ve been too unwilling to upset each other,” Rabbi Falcon told the crowd at the Presbyterian Church. “We try to honor the truth. This is the truth for you, and this is the truth for me. It may not be reconcilable, but it is important to refuse to make the other the enemy.”

They then recited what they regarded as untruth in their religions. The minster regarded “Christianity is the only way to God” as the untruth, the Rabbi referred to the notion of Jews as “the chosen people” and the Sheik referred to the “sword verses” in Koran like “kill the unbeliever”. He regarded this phrase as an “awkward phrase”. As one of the people present in the church said “Talking about the untruths of each tradition is very courageous. It gets it out of the platitude category and into dialogue.” However, I don’t think there is anything in Islam that can be regarded as untruth. Sheik Rahman said that some of the phrases are taken out of Koran without taking into consideration the context in which the phrases were used. He pointed out the Koran does not distinguish between literal, metaphorical and other phrases but we know that there are interpretations on the verses of Koran. Thus we have to refer to the interpretations before saying that there are “awkward versus” in Koran. Nowadays many have deviated from the straight path of Islam and what they represent to the world as Islam is not the real Islam brought to us by our prophet peace be upon him.Despite all these, the notion of inter-faith dialogue, I believe, is something that our society is really in need of. We in Iran have to express our religious ideas and also listen to what other religions have to say. This is especially important since the majority of people in Iran are Shia and there are many misunderstandings about this branch of Islam.
1. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Interfaith
* taken from http://www.nytimes.com/2009/11/24/us/24amigos.html
Saturday, November 21, 2009
Film Review

The Great Debaters
Director: Denzel Washington
Producers: Oprah Winfrey, Joe Roth, Bob Weinstein, Harvey Weinstein
Writers: Jeffrey Porro, Robert Eisele
Starring: Denzel Washington, Forest Whitaker, Nate Parker, Denzel Whitaker, Jurnee Smollett
Music: James Newton Howard
Cinematography: Philippe Rousselot
Editor: Hughes Winborne
Release date: December 25, 2007
Running time: 126 min
Country: United States
Language: English
Budget: $15 million
Gross revenue: $30,236,407
The Great Debaters is a 2007 American drama film. Denzel Washington, the director of the film who plays the role of Melvin Tolson, Wiley College English professor, has won the Academy Award twice. Also, Forest Whitaker is the other African-American playing in this film who has won the Academy Award for best actor in The Last King of Scotland. The film is based on a true story taken from the article written about the Wiley College debate team by Tony Scherman for the 1997 spring issue of American Legacy. Wiley College is a black college situated in Marshall, Texas. Melvin Tolson, English professor of the college, inspired by the Harlem Renaissance and his clandestine work as a union organizer, coaches a debate team in the college. The story takes place in 1935 when Jim Crow laws were common and lynch mobs were a great fear for blacks.

There are four people in the college team including, Samantha Booke, the first female in the college debate team and James Farmer, a precocious 14 year-old boy. The team, trained well by Tolson, defeats most of the other debate teams from different colleges and enters into the first debate between U.S students from white colleges and black colleges and the winner is Wiley. Having gained a lot of victories, the team is eventually invited to face Harvard University champions. This final debate is another victory for the Wiley College debate team.
The film beautifully portrays the Jim Crow south of America during the 1930s when the blacks were suffering so much from racism and lynch mobs. There are some moving scenes in the movie like the humiliation of a black doctor, James’s father, in front of his family over a dead pig or the scene where a black is lynched by a white mob who set his body afire. Although some people may think that these scenes take the focus off of the debating at times, I think they are essential to the film since they help us understand the characters better and the feelings that go into their debate arguments. Black life is all about segregation and discrimination and the audience have to see that black achievement and victory are not easily obtained.
The Great Debaters shows how the black realized that education was the key to their success. Mr. Farmer, James’s father, is the first African-American who manages to get a doctorate degree in Texas. He very much wants his son to follow his path and urges him to study hard. Also this emphasis on education and knowledge is seen in the scenes where Mr. Tolson is giving instructions to the debate team. He tells them that the whites have tried to keep their body, and kill their mind. They want to keep them psychologically dependent so that they can never improve and Tolson tells them that his is “trying to help save their righteous mind.”

The issues selected for debating are interesting. Long scenes are allotted to the young debaters expounding on school integration, civil disobedience and other big Issues. Although the speeches are prepared by Tolson, at the end we see the success of the team when they are left on their own to prepare themselves for the debate with Harvard.
Tolson’s being endangered by working as a covert labor organizer for local farmers and the team being threatened by lynch mobs remind the audience of the volatile politics of the time, when a black man could be attacked for simply owning a suit and a car. This gives the movie a nice political undertone.
The climactic debate at the end of the movie is between the Wiley College and Harvard University. However, based on the real story it should be between Wiley and the University of Southern California. This is done deliberately in order to highlight the great achievement of Wiley debate team.
Overall, I think The Great Debaters is an honest look at the 1930s Jim Crow south. It enjoys believable characters with solid acting and invokes emotional reactions in viewers. You can share the feelings of fear, shame, disgust, pride and happiness with the black people especially the debate team. Also this film shows us the great efforts of people who paved the way for civil-rights movement to happen. Tolson, the strong debating teacher, teaches the team members how to stand up for their rights and at the end of the film we learn that James becomes one of the leaders of the civil-rights movement and founds the Congress of Racial Equality. Finally I think that this movie is emotional, educational, and uplifting and arouses our feelings of sympathy for the black people.
http://oprah.about.com/od/harpoproductions/gr/greatdebaters.htm
http://www.bvonmovies.com/2007/12/25/the-great-debaters-review/
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0427309/plotsummary
http://www.variety.com/review/VE1117935673.html?categoryid=31&cs=1
http://movies.nytimes.com/2007/12/25/movies/25deba.html
Tuesday, November 17, 2009
Participation of U.S. citizens in 2000 and 2008 presidential elections


One of the manifestations of people’s interest in the political system of their country is their participation in elections. Voter turnout shows how important the system is for people and high voter turnout can make a country to be a representative democracy. United States claiming to be the representative of democracy has recently had a lower voter turnout in national elections comparing to European countries. “About 40 percent of the eligible adult population in the United States votes regularly, whereas 25 percent are occasional voters and 35 percent rarely or never vote.” (O’Connor et al, 2009, 347) There are different reasons for this low turnout. In this essay, I am going to investigate the voting behavior of American people by focusing on two presidential elections. 2000 presidential election is chosen as a case for which there was relatively low turnout and 2008 election is chosen as a case in which the U.S. had higher voter turnout comparing to the elections in the last few decades. These two cases should help us find out the reasons for people’s non-voting and voting.
In order to find out the voting behavior of people we need to know the factors that influence voter turnout and also the factors that lead voters to choose one candidate over another. O’ Connor at al (2009) state 6 factors that influence voter turnout. They are education, income, age, gender, race and ethnicity and interest in politics. Regarding the vote choice party identification and issues are stated as factors which influence individual’s choice.
In 2000 presidential election, 51.3 percent of the eligible voters, voted whereas the turnout for 2008 election was 62 percent. In 2000 presidential election the turnout was slightly above the lowest turnout in modern times which was 48.8 percent in 1996 election. However, in 2008 election the turnout was highest since 1996. Why was the turnout low in 2000 election? Considering the recent decrease in voter turnout, why did more people participate in 2008 election?
One of the reasons for low turnout according to McKay et al (2002) is the difficulty of registration for voting in America, as the burden of registration is put on the individual rather than the government. O’Connor et al (2009) add difficulty of absentee voting and great number of elections (twice as many national elections as other western democracies) as the other reasons for low voter turnout. These are the factors that normally affect all elections in the U.S. But as I am focusing on two cases of presidential election, I think we need to consider the situation of America before both elections to find out the reason for low turnout in 2000 election and higher one in 2008.
Before the 2000 election, President Clinton was in power since1992 for two terms. White House website delineates the period of Clinton’s administration as the time when “the U.S. enjoyed more peace and economic well being than at any time in its history.” Moreover, Clinton managed to “point to the lowest unemployment rate in modern times, the lowest inflation in 30 years, the highest home ownership in the country's history, dropping crime rates in many places, and reduced welfare rolls. He proposed the first balanced budget in decades and achieved a budget surplus.” Based on this description, therefore, it seems that at the time of 2000 election, there was no issue causing people to be worried. According to McKay et al (2002) low turnout may be a sign that people are generally happy with the system and they see no need to change it. I suppose that might be the reason for the low turnout in 2000 election and also the reason why Al Gore, the candidate of the Democratic Party, won the majority of people’s votes. Although Al Gore did not win the Electoral College votes, I think the majority of people chose him because they were happy with the previous system run by a Democrat. Moreover, economy is both the driving force for people’s participation in election and a determining factor for their choice. O’Connor et al (2009) believe that voters usually “reward the party in government during good economic times and punish the party in government during periods of economic downturn.” so, I think that in 2000 election, people felt no need to participate in the election and since they were happy with the party in government, majority voted for the same party again. However, Republican Party became the party in government and President Bush took office from 2000 up to 2008.
During Bush’s first term of office, United States did not experience a period of peace and stability domestically and got involved in two wars. September 11 endangered American people security leading to the launch of wars on terror. However, passage of time showed that there was no WMD in Iraq which was the reason for the initiation of the war in Iraq. The wars did cost a lot. People felt that President Bush had lied to them and as the American death toll increased day by day, people became disillusioned with the government. All these events together with economic crisis provided the incentive for people to participate in 2008 election. They really felt the need that their participation could make a difference. At this time when people were tired of the existing situation, Obama’s motto, ‘change’, suited public’s taste. Moreover, his rhetoric and his plans for economy and job creation seemed to be more promising than his rival, McCain.
Another important factor which led to the greater participation of minorities especially African-Americans was Obama’s race. According to the U.S. Census Bureau, 65 percent of blacks and 49 percent of Hispanics participated in the election resulting in higher voter turnout in 2008. 2008 presidential election also enjoyed an increase in young voter turnout. 53.4 percent of people between 18 to 24 years old voted in 2008 election while in 2000 only 45.3 percent participated. According to Erika Johansson, a project coordinator for Declare Yourself Survey “Many youth were dissatisfied with the current administration and caught onto the idea of change. In addition, young people gravitated toward common issues, such as the economy and climate change, that made it easy to come together.” Among the young people, many voted for Obama explaining that they chose him because for the first time in history he had paid attention to the youth. He was also more appealing to the youth since he was young and charismatic. 2008 presidential election enjoyed high voter turnout due to financial crisis and people disillusionment with Bush administration. Hence, they wanted to the current situation to change. As Obama promised to bring good changes and he was not from the party which people held accountable for their unfavorable situation, he managed to defeat his rival from the opposite party and win the election.
References:
1.McKay, D. Houghton, D. Wroe, A. 2002. Controversies in American Politics and Society. USA. Blackwell Publishing.
2.O’Connor, K. Sabato, L. Yanus, A. 2009. Essentials of American Government. USA. Pearson Education, Inc.
3.http://www.whitehouse.gov, retrieved on 2.11.09.
4.http://www.thetartan.org/2008/11/10/news/elections, retrieved on 01.11.09.
5.http://elections.gmu.edu/voter_turnout.htm , retrieved on 2.11.09
6.http://www.infoplease.com/ipa/A0781453.html, retrieved on 2.11.09
U.S. Mosque Seizure

Another move to increase tensions between the two countries. The U.S. seized four mosques and a New York City skyscraper owned by a Muslim nonprofit organization suspected of Iranian links. In what could prove to be one of the biggest counterterrorism seizures in U.S. history, prosecutors on Thursday 12th November filed a civil complaint in federal court against the Alavi Foundation, seeking the forfeiture of more than $500 million in assets. The assets include bank accounts; Islamic centers consisting of schools and mosques in New York, Maryland, California and Houston; more than 100 acres in Virginia; and a 36-story Manhattan office tower [1]. Iranian authorities have condemned this action. Parliament speaker, Ali Larijani denounced this disgraceful action saying that these moves show that President Barack Obama’s slogan for change was deceitful. It seems that Obama’s ‘changes’ are increasing the tensions between the two countries. Iran was expecting to see a New America with President Obama in power. However, now parliament speaker says that Obama is no different from Bush. Larijani said that confiscating the properties of Alvi Foundation and the extension of sanctions against Iran for another year was a real disgrace. Obama came with the slogan of change but changes are easy to say and hard to practice. So you cannot really expect big changes to happen while Obama is in office because he has to work within a system in which he has faith. At least we should be happy that the word ‘terror’ does not exist in Obama’s literature as much as it was in the Bush’s. This is a positive change!
1. http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2009/11/15/AR2009111500694.html
Powerpoint Presented in Class



A new introduction to American Studies
Chapter9: Industry and Technology
Author: Christopher Clark
Christopher Clark grew up in the London area, studied at the University of Warwick, and obtained his PhD in History at Harvard. He taught at the University of York for eighteen years, and was Professor of North American History at the University of Warwick for another seven years before moving to UConn in 2005. He is a specialist in 18th and 19th century North American and United States social and cultural history; the social history of economic life; the history of American capitalism; rural societies and industrialization; abolitionism and utopian communities and New England. His current research interests are rural society and land reform in the U.S. and overseas, c. 1750-1960. Some of his publications are Social Change in America from the Revolution to the Civil War and The Roots of Rural Capitalism: Western Massachusetts, 1780-1860
http://www.history.uconn.edu/people/clark.php
World's attention to the U.S. for:
1. Political system and ideologies
2. Technological advances and industrial power
*Industry and technology: hallmarks of American accomplishment symbolizing America as archetypal ‘modern’ society
*Benjamin Franklin epitomized the virtues of practical ingenuity and pursuit of useful knowledge
*A few poor colonists came to excel all nations
*Inventive figures like Franklin, Morse, Whitney: true subjects for the history of the U.S.
*Emergence of an industrial power from an overwhelmingly rural and agrarian society
*Connection between farm and factory, nature and machine helped shape the processes that drove industrial expansion
Four main phases of American industrial and technological change
From colonies to Civil War: between revolution and civil war a new manufacturing economy grew up in close connection with patterns of rural economic life
After the Civil War: manufacturing became modern, rural America still expanding which helped shape industrial growth
20th century: industrial and urban activities outstripped their rural origins
Postmodern era: tendency to conceal processes of production, connection between agriculture and industry obscured by other concerns
From colonies to Civil War
Roots of American industrial development in the colonial period
Iron production, house-based textile production, urban craft trades and ship building
Export of raw materials and producers’ goods from Britain to America
Industrial development: a means to secure a hard won political independence
Developments after the revolution:
i. Transfer of technologies to America from abroad
ii. Development of new technologies within the framework of American manufacture
The most dramatic innovations involved the establishment of machine-based factory process especially in textile industry
New textile technology introduced from England
1814 onwards, eastern Massachusetts: group of merchants invested in large-scale textile production in mills
1820, town of Lowell: grew rapidly into an industrial city with large mills drawing water power from the company’s dams and canals
Most manufacturing in the hands of craft workers and farm families
Small-scale producers produced different goods from shoes, tools and implements to pumps, metal ware, furniture and clocks
By 1820 American manufacturers achieved higher productivity than their British counterparts
Key factors influencing early American manufacturing:
Imported technology
Diffusion of mechanical skills across rural and urban populations
U.S. manufacturers outperformed their British counterparts by installing machinery where the British used hand-powered equipment
Hallmarks of antebellum industry: development of techniques for using machines to help make finished goods & produce the machines themselves
Early American machines: labor-saving
19th century: rapid growth in population and land area, plentiful land but scare labor, high labor wages
Scarcity of labor: incentive to introduce machinery to reduce the number of workers and lower the costs of wages
Early 19th century: capital scarcity as well as labor scarcity
Rapid expansion of machine-based industries after 1850s when immigrants from overseas helped reduce labor shortage
Rural character of early America fostered the adoption of mechanized techniques
Development of simple interchangeable devices by furniture makers, tool makers and wagon builders
Advances in gun making and clock making: British commissioners were sent to the U.S. to learn ‘the American system of manufactures’
Interest in inventiveness and experimentation with devises diffused among the people, many patents were issued
Early American achievement : capacity to use machines and make them
Yankee ingenuity Vs south slavery: claims about practical ingenuity: part of the sectional struggle leading to the civil war
South concentrated on staple-crop production using slave labor
Yankees worked for themselves, not relying on chattel slave to do their work from 1840 onwards, most immigrants avoided south
Reasons for North’s military success in the Civil War:
Economic diversity
Technical dominance of manufacturing
Supply and transport requirements essential for military operations
From Civil War to the Great Crash
Turning point in industrial development under the stimulus of war production , population growth and higher capital expenditure
By 1880 employment in manufacturing and mining exceeded that in agriculture
Farming: more mechanized except in the south
Processing activities such as meat-packing developed on an industrial scale
Iron, steel, coal: central components of technologies
Steel: provided rails, bridges and trains for railroad system and other construction purposes
1880s onwards: the first urban skyscraper office buildings the prime symbols of American modernity
By 1906 the average size of American manufactories had reached 67 workers whereas in 1869 it was less than 5
Considerable shifts towards mechanization
working conditions different from those of the antebellum period
Interchangeability became broadly feasible in the production of a range of products
Subdivision of work: many tasks were accomplished by relatively unskilled labor
Industrial technology: a system of interdependent parts capable of producing more than its individual components
Firm sizes & capital investment grew
Social contexts shaped the process of technical change
Growing workforces: growing influence of labor unions
1870s & 1880s: strike action and conflicts over wages
Companies pursued competitive advantage over rival firms and greater control over their own workforces
The effort to achieve optimum output led to the adoption of new techniques of shop-floor organization and management
By the end of 19th century: time-and-motion studies, premium-rate methods, production planning, system design were introduced to factory work
Lewis Mumford: “clock : the key machine of the modern industrial age”
First 2 decades of the 20th century: new techniques of closely managed production emerged in the new automobile industry
Michigan manufacturer, Henry Ford: evolved a culmination of various 19th century developments in the new production line methods
Ford evolved the moving assembly line by adopting the principles of efficient layout and division of tasks from the scientific management movement, the principle of interchangeability from 19th century machine production and sequencing and belt systems from the slaughterhouses of meat-packing industry
Ford evolved the moving assembly line in which the speed of production was controlled by management and the line itself was the instrument of labor discipline, Fordism, later called Mass Production
Toward the end of 19th century: institutional changes fostered further technological developments
From abroad: chemicals and electrical applications
From domestic developments: telephony, electricity, automobile and aviation technology
Immigration from Europe and other parts of the world affected technical change
Steel framers, elevators, electricity, chemical and petroleum-based technologies, automobiles and wireless transmission
Stimulus for industrial investment: growing market for consumption
Significant shift in the social character of invention
Edison: America's most prominent inventor, also noteworthy for pioneering new methods of industrial research based on capital investment and collaborative effort
Edison and his group adopted factory methods for the very process of invention itself
Inventiveness removed from domestic, individual environment and became corporatized
Ordinary people were now the subjects not the agents of industrial progress
Science finds, industry applies, man conforms
The state and the industrial complex
Most developments emerged in private sectors
Calvin Coolidge: the business of the U.S. is business
Industry and technology in private hands
Growing role of government as a sponsor of industrial development after World War II and the Great Depression
National Bureau of Standards: founded in 1901 to establish consistency and interchangeability across systems and manufacturers’ products.
Ford: you can have any color you like as long as it’s black
1929 to 1933: economic depression drove down industrial production
Under Roosevelt's New Deal ,government agencies played active parts especially in the areas where the private sector had failed
Technologies extended to rural areas
WW II brought government into industrial production more directly by manufacturing tanks, guns , ships and aircrafts
After WW II government kept close connection with industry
Symbiosis of government and industry produced many key developments like sending people to the moon in the late 1960s and early 1970s
A postmodern era
Dehumanizing character of industrial society
Industrial activity despoiling and polluting the landscape
Skepticism about the atomic power and space program
Japanese manufacturers’ use of ‘lean production’ techniques outstripped U.S. mass production methods developed by Ford
Plant closures and job losses
New technological developments replaced older industrial work
A shift in emphasis from manufacturing employment in the traditional sense toward s work based on service functions and communication of information
Knowledge and data: raw materials and output of new industries
Interest in knowledge about techniques of production faded
Many facets of production became concealed, micro technology worked in hidden ways only accessible to specialist understanding
Atomic technology in its military form spelled the potential for destroying the world
New technologies no longer seemed simply beneficial
American industry in national and international contexts
Shifts towards ‘postmodern’ interpretations of American industry influences its place in wider world history
All phases of industrial change contained important elements of U.S. involvement in developments overseas
i. Pre-Civil War: intersection of domestic social structures and cultural patterns with technology transfer across the Atlantic, growth of international commerce, arrival of great numbers of skilled and semi-skilled immigrants
ii. Mid 20th century: rise of state government, creation of military-industrial complex, emergence of America as global power
Early 20th century: more than half of the world’s biggest companies were American and the U.S was the largest importer of immigrant labor
Now only one-fifth or fewer of the world’s largest companies are American-based mainly caused by influences from other parts of the world especially Asia
Continuation of American economic leadership is challenged by the relative weakness of its industrial base
Key to American success in technology
Improvement on imitation
Tuesday, November 10, 2009
Fort Hood Massacre

Nothing seems to work. It’s like you have one choice left. The last choice and perhaps the worst one. You don’t want to be violent but it seems that’s the only way you can get rid of your nasty job. You don’t want to kill your Muslim brothers and sisters. Why don’t these people understand? You have long tolerated their insults. You wanted to quit but they didn’t let you. And now, you are faced with something you never expected. You are on the wrong side. You have to go and help the enemies of your Muslim brothers. What can you do? Is there a way out? You don’t want to hurt anyone but how can you stop them from sending you to Iraq? These thoughts are driving you crazy. And at last you go for the last option. Gun is the solution. Not the best one but the only one left. You know that your action is not justified but you do it anyway and you kill 13 people. This is what happened at Fort Hood, Texas, on Thursday 5th November. Nidal Malik Hassan, an army psychiatrist, did not want to go to Afghanistan. So he shot 13 people dead and injured 31. Now the story of Major Hassan’s shooting is all over the media. He is a Muslim. You hear and read this many times. Muslims are terrorists. But have we not seen such shootings in the army before? Aren’t many Americans the victims of gun? In fact “at Fort Hood some violence is too familiar.” According to New York Times “ Staff Sgt. Gilberto Mota, 35, and his wife, Diana, 30, an Army specialist, had returned to Fort Hood from Iraq last year when he used his gun to kill her, and then took his own life, the authorities say. In July, two members of the First Cavalry Division, also just back from the war with decorations for their service, were at a party when one killed the other. That same month, Staff Sgt. Justin Lee Garza, 28, under stress from two deployments, killed himself in a friend’s apartment outside Fort Hood.” Now the case of Hassan has turned into a means to attack Muslims. I don’t think these actions have got anything to do with religion especially Islam. Gun is a part of American culture. If you have no Gun, you are not an American. You are in the army, you have gun and you want to protect yourself. What do you do?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
